| | Age | Grade | Athlete | Time | ST | Team | Date | Meet |
| 1. | | 12 | Matt Metlitz | 16:20.5PR | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 2. | | 10 | Matthew Bearden | 16:26.1 | NJ | Ewing | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 3. | | 12 | John Arnone | 16:36.4PR | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 4. | | 12 | Oliver Song | 16:38.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 5. | | 12 | Michael Caracappa | 16:42.0PR | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 6. | | 12 | Patrick Hill | 16:53.3PR | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 7. | | 12 | Stefan Stark | 16:57.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 8. | | 12 | Matt Knowles | 17:00.0PR | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 9. | | 11 | John Cahill | 17:06.5 | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 10. | | 12 | Mohammed Sameeruddi... | 17:09.8PR | NJ | North Plainfield | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 11. | | 11 | Charles Williams | 17:13.4 | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 12. | | 12 | Haroldas Subertas | 17:14.0PR | NJ | Point Pleasant Boro | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 13. | | 11 | Dylan Cole | 17:16.0 | NJ | Shore Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 14. | | 11 | John Durrenberger | 17:17.0PR | NJ | Spotswood | Sep 8
| School Grounds Scrimmage |
| | | 10 | Travis Fodor | 17:17.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 16. | | 10 | James Cahill | 17:17.9PR | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 17. | | 11 | Arthur Eng | 17:21.8 | NJ | Holmdel | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 18. | | 12 | Joe Carney | 17:23.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 19. | | 12 | Kyle McNally | 17:24.6PR | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 20. | | 11 | Frank Quagliotti | 17:25.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Oct 2
| Brooks Paul Short Run 2009 |
| | | 11 | Jeremy Antivo | 17:25.0 | NJ | Rahway | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 22. | | 12 | Curtis Johnson | 17:26.1PR | NJ | Rahway | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 23. | | 11 | Dylan Tooher | 17:28.0 | NJ | Cinnaminson | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| | | 12 | Jon Friedel | 17:28.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 13
| vs. Rumson, Matawan and Raritan |
| 25. | | 12 | Kyle Monga | 17:29.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 20
| Monmouth County Championships |
| 26. | | 11 | Zach Fuentes | 17:31.5 | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 27. | | 11 | Patrick Waite | 17:32.0 | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 28. | | 12 | Steven Fuschetti | 17:34.7PR | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 29. | | 11 | John Wright | 17:37.0 | NJ | Shore Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 30. | | 11 | Karl Hahn | 17:37.1PR | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 21
| NJSIAA Meet of Champions |
| 31. | | 10 | Ryan Corbett | 17:38.5 | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 32. | | 12 | Joe Opinski | 17:40.0PR | NJ | Spotswood | Sep 8
| School Grounds Scrimmage |
| 33. | | 11 | Bryan Broderick | 17:40.1 | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 34. | | 12 | Liam Ayres | 17:42.8PR | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 35. | | 12 | Pete Iannuzzi | 17:43.7PR | NJ | Delran | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 36. | | 12 | Joe Chen | 17:45.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 37. | | 9 | Jack Baisley | 17:45.7 | NJ | Holmdel | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 38. | | 11 | Luke Harper | 17:48.9 | NJ | Rahway | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 39. | | 9 | Rocco Nannarello | 17:53.0 | NJ | Shore Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 40. | | 10 | Skyler Johnson | 17:56.0 | NJ | Point Pleasant Boro | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 41. | | 9 | Luke Kornblatt | 17:56.6PR | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 42. | | 12 | Dhaval Shah | 18:00.5PR | NJ | Matawan Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 43. | | 12 | Zachary Manning | 18:01.7PR | NJ | Red Bank Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 44. | | 12 | Colin English | 18:03.5PR | NJ | Manasquan | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 45. | | 12 | Justin Dean | 18:04.4PR | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 46. | | 10 | Scott Bender | 18:07.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 47. | | 11 | Jacob Yang | 18:08.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 20
| Monmouth County Championships |
| 48. | | 12 | Sam Walter | 18:14.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 49. | | 10 | Hakan Yuksei | 18:14.5 | NJ | Matawan Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 50. | | 11 | James Ting | 18:15.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 30
| Shore Conference JV/Freshmen |
| 51. | | 10 | Kort Boethig | 18:18.2 | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Nov 21
| NJSIAA Meet of Champions |
| 52. | | 12 | Jon Tai | 18:20.7 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 31
| Shore Conference Championships |
| 53. | | 12 | Christopher Elam | 18:21.0PR | NJ | Shore Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 54. | | 11 | Alex Jones | 18:24.0 | NJ | Shore Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 55. | | 12 | Tim Skinner | 18:26.0PR | NJ | Shore Regional | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 56. | | 12 | Evan Norwood | 18:27.8PR | NJ | Matawan Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 57. | | 12 | Andrew Hannah | 18:28.0PR | NJ | Manasquan | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| | | 10 | Michael Choie | 18:28.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 59. | | 12 | Frank Stabile | 18:29.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Oct 2
| Brooks Paul Short Run 2009 |
| 60. | | 11 | Isaiah Hampton | 18:30.8PR | NJ | Rahway | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 61. | | 11 | Michael Harris | 18:31.1 | NJ | Matawan Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 62. | | 10 | Mark Comayagua | 18:32.6PR | NJ | North Plainfield | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 63. | | 11 | Ian Christ | 18:32.9PR | NJ | Rumson-Fair Haven Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 64. | | 9 | Eric Williams | 18:35.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 65. | | 12 | Matt Sampson | 18:35.7PR | NJ | Manasquan | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 66. | | 11 | Dylan Spadaccini | 18:39.0 | NJ | Matawan Regional | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 67. | | 10 | Cristian Arrelo | 18:43.0PR | NJ | Delran | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| | | 12 | Jack Trimble | 18:43.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 30
| Shore Conference JV/Freshmen |
| 69. | | 12 | Brian Tsai | 18:44.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 70. | | 11 | William Harris | 18:44.9PR | NJ | Rahway | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 71. | | 10 | Timothy Birch | 18:45.0 | NJ | Matawan Regional | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 72. | | 10 | Vinay Nathan | 18:52.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 73. | | 12 | Eric Stewart | 18:54.0PR | NJ | Manasquan | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 74. | | 12 | Nathaniel Walkes | 19:01.9PR | NJ | Carteret | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 75. | | 12 | Gregory McCormack | 19:02.6PR | NJ | Matawan Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 76. | | 10 | Jeffrey Saccone | 19:04.0 | NJ | Spotswood | Oct 6
| Middlesex High School |
| 77. | | 10 | Andrew Stewart | 19:04.3 | NJ | Cinnaminson | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 78. | | 11 | Jorge Perez | 19:05.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Oct 2
| Brooks Paul Short Run 2009 |
| 79. | | 11 | Kieran Hall | 19:10.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 80. | | 10 | Jason McMullen | 19:13.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Sep 15
| vs. RBC and Manasquan |
| | | 12 | Samuel Broadbent | 19:13.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Oct 2
| Brooks Paul Short Run 2009 |
| 82. | | 11 | Gerhardt Gerckens | 19:14.0 | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 83. | | 10 | Garrett Seville | 19:16.8 | NJ | Delran | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 84. | | 12 | Sergio Santos | 19:17.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Oct 2
| Brooks Paul Short Run 2009 |
| 85. | | 12 | Zubah Kolubah | 19:17.1PR | NJ | North Plainfield | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 86. | | 10 | Matthew Stavenik | 19:19.0 | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 87. | | 10 | Anthony Simuro | 19:23.0PR | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 88. | | 9 | Joe Citro | 19:25.0 | NJ | Spotswood | Oct 13
| Cardinal McCarrick and Highland Park High Sch... |
| 89. | | 10 | Allen Chang | 19:27.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 90. | | 12 | Nick Ridgway | 19:28.0PR | NJ | Spotswood | Sep 29
| South River High School |
| 91. | | 12 | Matt Gasper | 19:28.4PR | NJ | Delran | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 92. | | 10 | John Affriol | 19:31.6 | NJ | Matawan Regional | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 93. | | - | Frank Cascio | 19:33.0PR | NJ | Raritan | Sep 26
| Cougar Cross Country Invitational |
| 94. | | 11 | Albert Montemuro | 19:35.9 | NJ | Cinnaminson | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 95. | | 12 | Ryan Johnson | 19:36.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 96. | | 9 | James Cardone | 19:36.8 | NJ | Point Pleasant Boro | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 97. | | 11 | Cody Slusser | 19:37.0 | NJ | Delaware Valley Reg | Oct 3
| Shore Coaches Invitational |
| 98. | | 10 | Brian Geiger | 19:38.6 | NJ | Manasquan | Nov 7
| NJSIAA Central Sectional Championship |
| 99. | | 11 | Raghaz Malhotra | 19:40.0 | NJ | Holmdel | Oct 23
| vs. Shore, Raritan and RBC |
| 100. | | 9 | Rich Ridgway | 19:42.0 | NJ | Spotswood | Sep 29
| South River High School |