| 1 | 15 | Bucknell,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:14:39.0 | Spread (1st 5) 24.0 |
| 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, (6), (7) |
| Michael McGowan, John Dugan, Glen Williams, Andrew Garcia-Garrison, Harrison Brakewood, (Peter Murray), (Luke Giugliano) |
| 14:42.0, 14:49.0, 14:57.0, 15:05.0, 15:06.0, (15:08.0), (15:10.0) |
| 2 | 54 | Susquehanna,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:18:06.0 | Spread (1st 5) 38.0 |
| 8, 9, 11, 12, 14, (14), (21) |
| John Crowe, Alex Price, Colin Eberhardt, Dan Isenebrg, Salvatore D'Angelo, (Brandon Mash), (Matt Pezza) |
| 15:19.0, 15:21.0, 15:44.0, 15:45.0, 15:57.0, (15:57.0), (16:08.0) |
| 3 | 74 | Juniata,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:19:12.0 | Spread (1st 5) 38.0 |
| 10, 13, 16, 17, 18, (19), (20) |
| Nate Alter, Nicholas Simpson, Reese Marrero, Xavier Cachon, Stephen Park, (Ryan Bogdan), (Matt Guetzlaff) |
| 15:24.0, 15:46.0, 15:59.0, 16:01.0, 16:02.0, (16:04.0), (16:05.0) |
| 4 | 129 | Mount Mercy (Iowa),
IA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:53:10.1 | Spread (1st 5) 2:01.5 |
| 22, 24, 25, 28, 30, (31), (32) |
| Tj Mosbach, Tyler Hartley, Evan Bowman, Mitch Johnson, Andre Moodie, (Tyler Steele), (Erik Ryan) |
| 21:34.8, 22:13.5, 22:35.1, 23:10.4, 23:36.3, (23:39.8), (24:16.3) |
| 5 | 138 | Coe,
IA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:55:14.4 | Spread (1st 5) 2:35.7 |
| 23, 26, 27, 29, 33, (34) |
| Shea Devine, Austin Springsteen, Charlie Dewar, Daniel Paradisi, Keenan McLaughlin, (Tanner McClenahan) |
| 21:51.3, 22:45.1, 22:55.8, 23:15.2, 24:27.0, (26:02.7) |
