| 1 | 47 | Indiana (Pa.),
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:14:29.9 | Spread (1st 5) 48.5 |
| 4, 5, 7, 15, 16, (18), (19) |
| Sam Lenze, Marco Cardone, Evan Weaver, Ethan Ribelin, Nate Kuntz, (Mitch Chunta), (Nathan Skodi) |
| 14:36.3, 14:39.3, 14:45.3, 15:04.2, 15:24.8, (15:28.6), (15:32.0) |
| 2 | 52 | Slippery Rock,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:14:27.6 | Spread (1st 5) 38.8 |
| 3, 10, 12, 13, 14, (17), (20) |
| Shannon Dooley, Benjamin Buckless, Devon Navaroli, Ozzy Moore, Troy Hart, (Nathan Eadie), (Alex Dickson) |
| 14:25.0, 14:54.6, 15:01.6, 15:02.6, 15:03.8, (15:25.6), (15:48.0) |
| 3 | 62 | Seton Hill,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:15:42.5 | Spread (1st 5) 1:26.0 |
| 2, 6, 11, 21, 22, (23), (25) |
| Benton Bickerton, Owen Keith, Donavin Meriweather, Al Lindstrom, Greg Overbeck, (Brayden Henninger), (Marcus Hartlage) |
| 14:23.6, 14:41.0, 14:59.5, 15:48.8, 15:49.6, (15:50.3), (16:12.7) |
| 4 | 68 | California (Pa.),
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 1:16:53.5 | Spread (1st 5) 2:32.7 |
| 1, 8, 9, 24, 26, (27) |
| Jonathan Thrush, Mason Jobe, Noah Bernarding, Blake Ristau, Haden Boutiller, (Matt Young) |
| 14:16.5, 14:47.6, 14:52.5, 16:07.7, 16:49.2, (17:07.8) |
