| 1. | So | | Jaime Villa Zapatero | 3:56.66a | MO | Drury | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 2. | Jr | | Michael Landy | 3:56.74a | IN | Indianapolis | Billy Hayes Invitational | Fri, May 8 |
| 3. | Jr | | Matt Zielske | 3:58.03a | IN | Southern Indiana | Rose-Hulman Twilight Meet | Fri, Apr 17 |
| 4. | Fr | | Nate Dotterweich | 3:58.12a | KY | Bellarmine | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 5. | Jr | | Geoff Hughes | 3:58.41a | MO | Drury | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 6. | Fr | | Jason Barry | 3:58.84a | MO | Missouri S&T | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 7. | Fr | | Scott Tanis | 3:58.97a | IL | Lewis | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 8. | Sr | | Jason Thornsberry | 3:59.63a | KY | Bellarmine | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 9. | Fr | | Case VanArkel | 3:59.71a | MO | Drury | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 10. | So | | Ryne Smith | 4:00.59a | KY | Northern Kentucky | Miami Invitational | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 11. | Fr | | Alex Jones | 4:01.55a | KY | Bellarmine | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 12. | So | | Dustin Baldwin | 4:01.81a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 13. | Jr | | Charles Yeager | 4:02.28a | MO | Drury | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 14. | Fr | | Jordan Parayil | 4:03.01a | KY | Bellarmine | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 15. | So | | Brendan Smith | 4:04.18a | MO | Missouri S&T | Kansas Relays | Sat, Apr 18 |
| 16. | So | | Drew Harris | 4:04.49a | KY | Northern Kentucky | Miami Invitational | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 17. | Fr | | Marc Amarillas | 4:04.62a | IL | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville | Cougar Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 18. | Fr | | Sean Feehan | 4:04.74a | MO | Missouri S&T | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| Jr | | Justin Smith | 4:04.74a | KY | Bellarmine | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 20. | So | | Derek Berry | 4:04.81a | MO | Drury | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| Jr | | Matthew Shoulta | 4:04.81a | KY | Northern Kentucky | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 22. | So | | Shawn Dillard | 4:05.22a | IL | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville | Cougar Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 23. | Fr | | Alexander Mena | 4:05.72a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Bison Outdoor Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 24. | Fr | | Drew Thomas | 4:05.98a | MO | Missouri S&T | CMU Open | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 25. | Fr | | Dan Coats | 4:06.3 | KY | Bellarmine | EKU Open | Fri, Apr 17 |
| 26. | So | | Chris Yates | 4:06.37a | MO | Drury | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 27. | So | | Allen Ernst | 4:07.02a | MO | Missouri S&T | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 28. | Fr | | Eric Fairbairn | 4:07.98a | MO | Missouri S&T | UTA Bobby Lane Invitational | Sat, Mar 28 |
| 29. | Sr | | Patrick Walsh | 4:08.01a | IL | Lewis | Hillsdale College Gina Relays | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 30. | So | | Eric Dwyer | 4:08.08a | KY | Northern Kentucky | Hillsdale College Gina Relays | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 31. | Jr | | Andy Chase | 4:08.10a | MO | Drury | Dewey Allgood Invitational | Sat, Apr 18 |
| 32. | Sr | | Greg Robinson | 4:08.2 | KY | Bellarmine | EKU Open | Fri, Apr 17 |
| 33. | So | | Corey Spriggs | 4:09.95a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Mike Poehlein Invitational | Sat, Apr 4 |
| 34. | So | | Bryan McLoone | 4:09.98a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 35. | Sr | | Terrell Brown | 4:10.41a | KY | Bellarmine | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 36. | So | | Josh Gornall | 4:11.14a | IN | Indianapolis | Oliver Nikoloff Invitational | Sat, Mar 28 |
| 37. | Sr | | Jeff Ritzema | 4:11.16a | IL | Lewis | Chicagolands | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 38. | So | | Guy Vandermosten | 4:11.62a | KY | Bellarmine | Boston/Moon Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 39. | Fr | | LaQuan Fenderson | 4:11.66a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Raleigh Relays | Sat, Mar 28 |
| 40. | Fr | | Danny McMahon | 4:12.85a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Spring Fling | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 41. | Jr | | Cody Parks | 4:14.27a | IN | Indianapolis | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 42. | Sr | | Thomas Green | 4:14.45a | MO | Missouri S&T | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 43. | Fr | | Rehan Mahmood | 4:14.75a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Early Spring Opener | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 44. | Sr | | Kevin Dockemeyer | 4:14.76a | IL | Lewis | Eagle Invitational | Sat, Apr 18 |
| 45. | Fr | | Andrew Piropato | 4:15.15a | IN | Indianapolis | Early Bird Relays | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 46. | Sr | | Chad Bowling | 4:15.16a | KY | Bellarmine | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 47. | So | | Neal Masterson | 4:15.50a | KY | Bellarmine | Centre Invitational | Sat, Apr 4 |
| 48. | Sr | | Steven Werths | 4:15.57a | IL | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville | Cougar Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 49. | Fr | | Joe Skelton | 4:16.46a | MO | Missouri S&T | CMU Open | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 50. | Sr | | Matt VanArkel | 4:16.49a | MO | Drury | Dewey Allgood Invitational | Sat, Apr 18 |
| 51. | So | | Michael Renkowski | 4:17.09a | MO | Missouri S&T | CMU Open | Sat, Mar 21 |
| Sr | | Andy Rogers | 4:17.09a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Mike Poehlein Invitational | Sat, Apr 4 |
| 53. | Fr | | Andrew Duggan | 4:18.02a | IN | Southern Indiana | Stan Lyons Open | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 54. | Jr | | Jay Skibbens | 4:19.00a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Spring Fling | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 55. | Fr | | Travis Strock | 4:19.04a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Spring Fling | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 56. | Jr | | Glen Buttrum | 4:20.19a | MO | Drury | Bob Laptad /Bill Williams Invitational | Fri, Apr 24 |
| 57. | Fr | | Justin McIntyre | 4:20.89a | KY | Northern Kentucky | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 58. | Fr | | Ben Orvold | 4:22.07a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Early Spring Opener | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 59. | Fr | | Rigoberto Bernal | 4:22.10a | IL | Lewis | Chicagolands | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 60. | Jr | | Sean Gosewisch | 4:22.16a | IL | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville | Cougar Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 61. | Jr | | Val Ploetz | 4:22.17a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Spring Fling | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 62. | Sr | | Kyle Cameron | 4:22.66a | IL | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville | Joey Haines Invitational | Sat, Apr 4 |
| 63. | So | | Robert Meyers | 4:23.38a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Warrior Invitational | Sat, Mar 28 |
| 64. | So | | Seth Schultz | 4:23.53a | IL | Lewis | Chicagolands | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 65. | So | | Hunter Durden | 4:26.06a | KY | Northern Kentucky | Hillsdale College Gina Relays | Sat, Apr 25 |
| 66. | Jr | | Chris Teel | 4:28.06a | MO | Missouri S&T | UTA Bobby Lane Invitational | Sat, Mar 28 |
| 67. | So | | Daniel Childers | 4:28.52a | MO | Drury | Gorilla Classic | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 68. | Sr | | Rob Hansen | 4:28.85a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Early Spring Opener | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 69. | Fr | | Matt Vidas | 4:29.53a | WI | Wisconsin-Parkside | Early Spring Opener | Sat, Mar 21 |
| 70. | - | | Greg Thome | 4:30.53a | MO | Missouri S&T | Dewey Allgood Invitational | Sat, Apr 18 |
| 71. | Fr | | Jon Duty | 4:30.73a | IN | Indianapolis | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 72. | Fr | | Alex Bettag | 4:32.08a | KY | Bellarmine | Hanover Invitational | Sat, Mar 28 |
| 73. | So | | Naza Sanchez | 4:32.15a | IN | St Joseph's (IN) | Mike Poehlein Invitational | Sat, Apr 4 |
| 74. | - | | Daniel Mann | 4:32.37a | MO | Missouri S&T | Dewey Allgood Invitational | Sat, Apr 18 |
| 75. | Fr | | John Deutsch | 4:32.76a | IL | Lewis | Chicagolands | Sat, Apr 11 |
| 76. | So | | Cole Schroer | 4:36.48a | IN | Southern Indiana | Washington University Invitational | Sat, Apr 4 |
| 77. | Sr | | Vince Taylor | 4:36.84a | IN | Indianapolis | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 78. | Sr | | Brent Rehkemper | 4:57.65a | IL | Southern Illinois-Edwardsville | Gregory Invitational | Fri, May 15 |
| 79. | Jr | | Cory Fornal | 5:11.58a | IN | Indianapolis | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 80. | Jr | | Peter Hollenbeck | 5:21.29a | MO | Missouri S&T | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 81. | Sr | | Wes Leeper | 5:23.55a | IN | Indianapolis | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 82. | Jr | | Pat Reaney | 5:31.13a | IL | Lewis | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 83. | So | | Kyle White | 5:33.46a | KY | Bellarmine | Great Lakes Valley Conference Championships | Sat, May 2 |
| 84. | Sr | | Jeff Zoellick | 1520a.0 | IL | Lewis | Herschel Neil Decathlon/Ashley Nally Heptathlon | Mon, Mar 30 |