| 1. | - | Isaac McReynolds Darius Law Demario House Sam Jordan | 40.56a | North Carolina-Charl... | |
| 2. | - | A'Tolani Akinkuotu Reggie Reese Miles Walker Shawn Murray | 40.98a | North Carolina State | |
| 3. | - | Deshawn Lee Eric Plump Darrius Baker Chazwyn Price | 41.65a | Savannah State | |
| 4. | - | Nick Dodson Shaun Kennedy Montez Valentine Randall Dameron | 41.78a | Shorter | |
| 5. | - | Dewayne Chandler Devonte Guyon Reggie Hill Jake Wainwright | 42.33a | North Carolina-Charl... | |
| 6. | - | Anthony Adamski Keith Ogden Derrick Bass Jeff Robinson | 42.83a | Millersville | |
| 7. | - | Charles Sulick Theo Facinoli Keary Simms Fredrick Williams | 42.93a | Winthrop | |
| 8. | - | Stephon Knox John Natow Michael Meadows Kevoy Douglas | 43.00a | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 9. | - | Relay Team | 43.02a | Davidson | |
| 10. | - | Antonio Lipscomb D'Juan Thurmond Kahlil Knuckles Marquis Greene | 43.40a | Limestone | |
| 11. | - | Relay Team | 43.72a | Morgan State | |
| 12. | - | Bryan Wideman Bill Zaccardelli Tony Mihalich Matt Mihalich | 43.89a | John Carroll | |
| 13. | - | Joshua Logan Octavius Matthews Hunter Waldron Derrick Tinsley | 44.38a | Livingstone | |
| 14. | - | David Hickey Drew Krainz Mike Minjock Matt Szep | 44.52a | John Carroll | |
| 15. | - | Jorrell Nugent Ryan Griffith Christopher Wallace Jack Scanlin | 44.52a | Millersville | |
| 16. | - | Chase Fuller Bo Miller Codi Merritt Bryce Nixon | 44.98a | Gardner-Webb | |
| 17. | - | Andrew Borrasso Brendan Coyne Bob Wolf Jake Fishbein | 45.18a | Kenyon | |
| 18. | - | Jason Robinson Spencer German Gino Giammo Mike Hlatky | 45.71a | John Carroll | |
| -- | - | Raldaine McDonald Weymour Johnson Darren Campbell Zacharia Ahmed | DNF | Fairleigh Dickinson-... | |
| -- | - | William Jordan Kevin Shelf Tim Handy Linwood Jenkins | DNF | Livingstone | |
| 1. | - | Winston Brown Leford Green Everette Berry Jamille Callum | 3:13.98a | Johnson C. Smith | |
| 2. | - | Relay Team | 3:16.10a | North Carolina State | |
| 3. | - | Tadarrin Phronebarger Devonte Guyon Chase Eckard Derrick Eure | 3:17.92a | North Carolina-Charl... | |
| 4. | - | Anthony Taylor Montez Valentine Nick Dodson Terrence Scruggs | 3:18.19a | Shorter | |
| 5. | - | Chazwyn Price Deshawn Lee Etchien Assinzo Gabriel Davis | 3:20.81a | Savannah State | |
| 6. | - | Ryan Williamson Shavar Watson Richard Ibeh Alfonso Banks | 3:20.97a | King College | |
| 7. | - | Deandre Robinson Isaac Richardson Carbinere Whyte Jude Obiarinze | 3:21.63a | Morgan State | |
| 8. | - | Demario House Reggie Hill James Savoy Darius Law | 3:22.25a | North Carolina-Charl... | |
| 9. | - | Bill Zaccardelli David Hickey Anthony Colbert Tony Mihalich | 3:22.33a | John Carroll | |
| 10. | - | Weymour Johnson Raldaine McDonald Ahmed Amarouch Darren Campbell | 3:23.08a | Fairleigh Dickinson-... | |
| 11. | - | A.J. Baker Allen O'Neal Shaun Kennedy Marchello Sinkfield | 3:25.44a | Shorter | |
| 12. | - | Theo Facinoli Charles Sulick Adam Leroux Drew Franklin | 3:27.07a | Winthrop | |
| 13. | - | Relay Team | 3:27.27a | Davidson | |
| 14. | - | Briann Russell Antonio Lipscomb Travis Tolliver D'Juan Thurmond | 3:27.74a | Limestone | |
| 15. | - | Cameron Thomas Dustin Thomas Danny Moore Mike Meissner | 3:31.30a | South Carolina Upstate | |
| 16. | - | Kent King Jonathan Jackson Andre Collins Anthony Cureton | 3:32.30a | Johnson C. Smith | |
| 17. | - | Javan Lapp David Eubanks Will Taylor Dakota Lowery | 3:32.55a | North Carolina-Charl... | |
| 18. | - | Andrew Borrasso Brendan Coyne Pat Meyers Bob Wolf | 3:34.09a | Kenyon | |
| 19. | - | Matt Szep John Jackson Drew Krainz Matt Mihalich | 3:35.02a | John Carroll | |
| 20. | - | Hunter Waldron Octavius Matthews Derrick Tinsley William Jordan | 3:35.85a | Livingstone | |
| 21. | - | Zaky Kalil Wesley Redfern Jose Lopez Derrick Barner | 3:36.99a | Morgan State | |
| 22. | - | Jordan Yarbrough Chris Murray Simon Haake Ian Boyd | 3:38.20a | North Carolina-Ashev... | |
| 23. | - | Stephen Kedzuf John Coughlin Mike Coughlin Jason Robinson | 3:52.88a | John Carroll | |
| -- | - | Codi Merritt Josiah Stanton-Brooks Evan Brusich Charlie Steinke | DNF | Gardner-Webb | |
| -- | - | Bryan Wideman Mike Minjock Spencer German Gino Giammo | FS | John Carroll | |