| 1. | - | Ryan Fleming Francisque Pierre-Jerome Evan Heyman Jacob Schwab | 41.90a | Ohio Northern | |
| 2. | - | Anton Bowman Brandon Evans Kwarteng Asare Nathan Joyce | 43.82a | Christopher Newport | |
| 3. | - | Nicholas Chisholm Justin Lyttleton Eugene O'hanlon Kevin Defranco | 43.98a | University of Rochester | |
| 4. | - | Barnik Saha Tim Kikta Noel Titus Dustin Musselman | 44.19a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 5. | - | Caleb Getty Steve Roberts Jeff Hunsicker Larry Glace | 44.34a | Lock Haven | |
| 6. | - | Isaac Hayes Daniel Piccolo Tony Rodriguez Dalton Echard | 44.56a | Mary Washington | |
| 7. | - | Ryan Adams Ngoni Tengatenga Peter Deraska Royce Brown | 44.66a | Trinity (CT) | |
| 8. | - | Jacob Stone Sean LaFontaine Kendall Bates Sean Sewell | 46.11a | Huntington | |
| -- | - | Michael Cohara Matt Jurcak Andrew Barnhart Erik Williams | DQ | Case Western Reserve | |
| -- | - | Randy Lott Steven Cole Devin Parker Tracey Johnson | DQ | Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 1. | - | Garrett Brown Evan Heyman Shane Huntley Jacob Schwab | 3:18.04a | Ohio Northern | |
| 2. | - | James Alexander Felix Kitur Jacob Lysher Kyle Fuller | 3:18.15a | VMI | |
| 3. | - | Sean Harper Paul Stults Caleb Getty Steve Roberts | 3:19.70a | Lock Haven | |
| 4. | - | Kane Thomas Dillon Myers Mac Keers Alexander Tallman | 3:20.54a | Washington & Lee | |
| 5. | - | Ben Nealy Daniel Ching Tim Kikta Dustin Musselman | 3:23.68a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 6. | - | Kwarteng Asare Nathan Joyce Jeffrey Ball SHAOWEI TU | 3:26.87a | Christopher Newport | |
| 7. | - | Justin Lyttleton Nicholas Chisholm Andrew Keene Andrew Lee | 3:28.32a | University of Rochester | |
| 8. | - | Colton Linton Tucker Cunningham Jamison Monahan Chase Board | 3:28.50a | Roanoke | |
| 9. | - | Ngoni Tengatenga John Mason Stephen Creane Ricky Lynn | 3:28.97a | Trinity (CT) | |
| 10. | - | Sean LaFontaine Ethan Medley Kendall Bates Sean Sewell | 3:30.45a | Huntington | |
| 11. | - | Stefan Njomo Randy Lott AJ Mills Steven Cole | 3:31.03a | Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 12. | - | Wilson Bever Scott Teribury Brian Huffman Anthony Harris | 3:31.79a | Christopher Newport | |
| 13. | - | Andrew Ballinger Kyle Buzby Andreas Diaz-Borda Walter Goodwin | 3:35.92a | Stevens IT (NJ) | |
| 14. | - | Trey Hatcher Wayde Marsh Brian Palmer Vergil Parson | 3:38.32a | Washington & Lee | |
| 15. | - | Matt Harvey Chris Kittle Joakim Kiprotich Abraham Jordan | 3:41.10a | VMI | |
| 16. | - | Douglas McLellan Jeremy Scroggins Dominic Yanger Christopher Mogensen | 3:43.72a | Christopher Newport | |
| -- | - | Noel Titus Jaime Trujillo James Allen Robert Cross | DNF | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 1. | - | Corey Lofton Scott Teribury Jeffrey Ball SHAOWEI TU | 7:58.48a | Christopher Newport | |
| 2. | - | Felix Kitur Andrey Dmitriev Jacob Lysher Dean Gonsalves | 7:58.92a | VMI | |
| 3. | - | Corey Bailey Evan McKee Travis Isenberg Mathew Johnson | 8:08.17a | Ohio Northern | |
| 4. | - | Mark Grogan Chris Kelly Brett Beaugureau Bobby Voigt | 8:20.51a | Case Western Reserve | |
| 5. | - | Douglas McLellan Wilson Bever William Kirk Chris Allen | 8:28.19a | Christopher Newport | |
| 6. | - | Louie Stengel Kyle Buzby Michael Cahill Andrew Ballinger | 8:45.29a | Stevens IT (NJ) | |