| 1. | Jr | Caleb Muller | 14:42.43a | Marietta | |
| 2. | So | Josh Newby | 15:03.89a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 3. | Sr | Ermin Mujezinovic | 15:05.90a | VMI | |
| 4. | Sr | Noah Hagos | 15:05.91a | VMI | |
| 5. | Sr | Patrick McLaughlin | 15:07.17a | Allegheny | |
| 6. | So | Ryan Taylor | 15:08.55a | Shenandoah | |
| 7. | Jr | Dustin Adams | 15:08.88a | Shippensburg | |
| 8. | Jr | Chris Kelly | 15:14.69a | Case Western Reserve | |
| 9. | Sr | Josiah Renton | 15:16.68a | Shenandoah | |
| 10. | Sr | Sean Whitson | 15:19.37a | Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 11. | So | Darren Driscoll | 15:19.83a | Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 12. | Sr | Jake Garcia | 15:20.39a | Shenandoah | |
| 13. | So | Cabell Willis | 15:25.48a | VMI | |
| 14. | | David Angell | 15:26.31a | Unattached | |
| 15. | So | William Thompson | 15:27.43a | VMI | |
| 16. | Jr | Caleb Ellis | 15:27.93a | Marietta | |
| 17. | So | Cody Stanton | 15:32.02a | Lynchburg | |
| 18. | Sr | Brandon Demers | 15:33.22a | Lynchburg | |
| 19. | Sr | Dean Gonsalves | 15:38.85a | VMI | |
| 20. | Jr | Billy Littlefield | 15:43.54a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 21. | Sr | Rob Morhard | 15:43.91a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 22. | So | Ken Murphy | 15:44.43a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 23. | Jr | Kevin Edwards | 15:45.62a | Allegheny | |
| 24. | Fr | Hartnel Paultre | 15:48.05a | VMI | |
| 25. | Sr | Kyle Andrews | 15:57.60a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 26. | Sr | Bradford Antes | 16:02.69a | Stevens IT (NJ) | |
| 27. | Fr | James Rynes | 16:03.84a | Allegheny | |
| 28. | So | Kane Thomas | 16:06.05a | Washington & Lee | |
| 29. | So | Corey Williams | 16:06.55a | Case Western Reserve | |
| 30. | So | Daniel Nafziger | 16:10.33a | Eastern Mennonite | |
| 31. | So | David Brown | 16:15.52a | Lynchburg | |
| 32. | So | Andrew Stoddard | 16:16.48a | Hampden-Sydney | |
| 33. | Fr | Daniel Ferrell | 16:23.87a | Lynchburg | |
| 34. | So | Evan Breitsch | 16:26.21a | Allegheny | |
| 35. | | Tyler Gehrs | 16:26.52a | Unattached | |
| 36. | Fr | John Williamson | 16:29.27a | Denison | |
| 37. | Fr | Alex Smith | 16:31.05a | Washington & Lee | |
| 38. | Fr | Alex Simon | 16:34.88a | Allegheny | |
| 39. | | Jordan Chang | 16:41.62a | Unattached | |
| 40. | Sr | Chris Dunn | 16:44.82a | Denison | |
| 41. | - | Tom Cunningham | 16:46.69a | Stevens IT (NJ) | |
| 42. | Fr | Joseph McMahon | 16:47.16a | Lynchburg | |
| 43. | Sr | Robert Warneford-Thompson | 16:48.49a | Washington & Lee | |
| 44. | Jr | James Grasso | 16:49.52a | Washington & Lee | |
| 45. | Jr | Steven Johnson | 16:50.91a | Denison | |
| 46. | So | Kyle Lombardi | 16:52.27a | Shenandoah | |
| 47. | Fr | Jacob Brennan | 16:56.80a | Shenandoah | |
| 48. | Fr | Chris Monroe | 17:11.24a | Marietta | |
| 49. | Fr | Logan Eckels | 17:16.26a | Marietta | |
| 50. | | James Busch | 17:18.65a | Unattached | |
| 1. | - | Michael Treese Tyrek Nelson Robert Bales Herman Kirkland | 42.53a | Shippensburg | |
| 2. | - | Lucas Hellwig Ryan Householder Charles Dixon William McCulloch | 43.15a | Marietta | |
| 3. | - | Aaron Jeong Alexander Tallman Parker Howard Steven Collieu | 43.42a | Washington & Lee | |
| 4. | - | Matt Gaddy Nathan Joyce Kwarteng Asare Robert Mayes | 43.45a | Christopher Newport | |
| 5. | - | Randy Lott Ethan Fowlkes Chris Boothe Dan Elmore | 44.97a | Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 6. | - | Vinny Mwano AJ Mills Tristan Boysaw Zachary Kezar | 45.35a | Lynchburg | |
| 7. | - | Chris Roth Ivanhoe Hall Robert Fox Joe Nichols | 46.14a | Denison | |
| 1. | - | Robert Bales Andrew Kujawski Tyrek Nelson Eric Wolfe | 3:15.91a | Shippensburg | |
| 2. | - | Tom Troxell Joel Flott Eric Bologa Kevin Shaw | 3:20.55a | Shippensburg | |
| 3. | - | Mac Keers Parker Howard Steven Collieu Alexander Tallman | 3:21.14a | Washington & Lee | |
| 4. | - | Mike Standish Ben Nealy Thomas Vandenberg Noel Titus | 3:21.85a | Carnegie Mellon | |
| 5. | - | Charles Dixon Cody Strahler Kyle Connery Ryan Householder | 3:22.34a | Marietta | |
| 6. | - | Nathan Joyce Robert Mayes Matt Gaddy Wilson Bever | 3:25.61a | Christopher Newport | |
| 7. | - | Evan Ellison Rachad Davis Curtis Whitlow Edmond Hawi | 3:26.23a | Lynchburg | |
| 8. | - | Colton Linton Chase Board Caleb Bledsoe Tucker Cunningham | 3:26.74a | Roanoke | |
| 9. | - | Randy Lott Dominique Sheard Conner White Dan Elmore | 3:34.08a | Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 10. | - | Robert Fox Ivanhoe Hall Steven Czujko Joe Thackery | 3:38.59a | Denison | |
| -- | - | Jonathan Jackson Kyle Fuller Brandon Hartman Felix Kitur | DQ | VMI | |
| 1. | - | Matthew Bee Ryan Spangler Tom Troxell Tom Kehl | 7:56.33a | Shippensburg | |
| 2. | - | Matt Oldroyd Bernard England Matthew Ahearn Joel Flott | 7:57.67a | Shippensburg | |
| 3. | - | William Orndorff Curtis Whitlow Lawrence Minor Reid Taylor | 8:11.73a | Lynchburg | |
| 4. | - | James Grasso Scott Sugden Nick Richardson John Sauer | 8:18.69a | Washington & Lee | |
| 5. | - | David Dixon Chris Kelly Jim Mather Michael Perisa | 8:18.77a | Case Western Reserve | |
| 6. | - | Jake Lafaver Matt Fedrizzi Phillip Schier Tim Rutan | 8:37.86a | Nazareth | |
| 7. | - | Steven Czujko Joe Thackery Steven Johnson Connor Ford | 8:40.94a | Denison | |
| 8. | - | Agustin Kim Tyler Grant Arthur Stier Alexander Tallman | 8:57.56a | Washington & Lee | |