| 1. | - | Christopher Kelley John Mikalik Bert Green Hanneus Ollison | 40.54a | McMurry University | |
| 2. | - | Relay Team | 40.77a | Nebraska Wesleyan | |
| 3. | - | Relay Team | 40.78a | Christopher Newport | |
| 4. | - | Segun Olopo Azizuddin Rose Mike Conti Matthew Harden | 41.09a | Illinois Wesleyan | |
| 5. | - | Relay Team | 41.21a | Ramapo | |
| 6. | - | Marcus Lee Jaymark Bailey Marc Robinson Sherman Goree | 41.22a | New Jersey City U | |
| 7. | - | Brad Koback Pat Leonard Nick Ver Duin Keith Ingram | 41.23a | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | |
| 8. | - | Kevin Ma John Riese Stanley Cadet Matthew Bieringer | 41.71a | SUNY Cortland | |
| 9. | - | Relay Team | 44.66a | Methodist | |
| 1. | - | Christopher Kelley John Mikalik Bert Green Hanneus Ollison | 40.47a | McMurry University | |
| 1. | - | Relay Team | 40.89a | Nebraska Wesleyan | |
| 1. | - | Segun Olopo Azizuddin Rose Mike Conti Matthew Harden | 40.91a | Illinois Wesleyan | |
| 2. | - | Brad Koback Pat Leonard Nick Ver Duin Keith Ingram | 40.94a | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | |
| 2. | - | Relay Team | 40.94a | Christopher Newport | |
| 3. | - | Kevin Ma John Riese Matthew Bieringer Amaan Siddeeq | 40.98a | SUNY Cortland | |
| 4. | - | Relay Team | 41.15a | Ramapo | |
| 2. | - | Marcus Lee Jaymark Bailey Marc Robinson Sherman Goree | 41.28a | New Jersey City U | |
| 5. | - | Relay Team | 41.28a | Methodist | |
| 3. | - | Brandon Copeland Melvin Queen Tyler Beiler Tony Konate | 41.32a | Bridgewater (VA) | |
| 3. | - | Chris Bradford Sam Moen Phil Bastron Joe DeFrance | 41.40a | St Thomas (MN) | |
| 4. | - | Jim LePorte Tyler Faits Alex Greenhouse Freddy Linton | 41.53a | Emory | |
| 4. | - | Relay Team | 41.79a | Salisbury | |
| 5. | - | Relay Team | 41.98a | Lynchburg | |
| - | Blake Obuchowski Herman Reeves Patrick Offner Keith Newhouse | DQ | University of Chicago | |
| 1. | - | Brad Koback Nick Ver Duin Kyle Steiner Pat Leonard | 3:12.09a | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | |
| 2. | - | Matt Patrick Alex Miller Luke Bolander Guy Dierikx | 3:12.75a | Central College (IA) | |
| 3. | - | Relay Team | 3:13.30a | McMurry University | |
| 4. | - | Andrew Arons Deividas Seferis Taylor Fitzgerald Alex Hoerman | 3:13.52a | Williams | |
| 5. | - | Alex Greenhouse Tyler Faits Jason Campbell Freddy Linton | 3:14.22a | Emory | |
| 6. | - | Jon Howard Adam Pennington Adam Johnson Greg Jackson | 3:14.23a | North Central | |
| 7. | - | Taylor Ferda Zach Schlegel Eric Rhode Joshua Otto | 3:14.77a | Bethel (MN) | |
| 8. | - | Evan Holschbach Kyle Ekberg Matt Somers Ted McMillan | 3:15.00a | Augustana (IL) | |
| 9. | - | Segun Olopo Mike Conti Noah Dunham Matthew Harden | 3:18.93a | Illinois Wesleyan | |
| 1. | - | Matt Patrick Alex Miller Luke Bolander Guy Dierikx | 3:13.99a | Central College (IA) | |
| 2. | - | Evan Holschbach Kyle Ekberg Matt Somers Ted McMillan | 3:14.00a | Augustana (IL) | |
| 3. | - | Jon Howard Adam Pennington Adam Johnson Greg Jackson | 3:14.42a | North Central | |
| 4. | - | Alex Greenhouse Tyler Faits Jason Campbell Freddy Linton | 3:14.54a | Emory | |
| 1. | - | Brad Koback Nick Ver Duin Josh Schwinn Pat Leonard | 3:14.62a | Wisconsin-Stevens Point | |
| 5. | - | Taylor Ferda Zach Schlegel Eric Rhode Joshua Otto | 3:14.79a | Bethel (MN) | |
| 2. | - | Relay Team | 3:15.29a | McMurry University | |
| 1. | - | Andrew Arons Deividas Seferis Taylor Fitzgerald Alex Hoerman | 3:15.53a | Williams | |
| 3. | - | Derek Carson Andy Coppersmith Evan Knight Chris Wolf | 3:15.63a | Nebraska Wesleyan | |
| 4. | - | Chris Word Will Tolbert Brandon Edwards Earl Graves | 3:15.92a | Lynchburg | |
| 5. | - | Gino Bisceglia John Riese Adam Groesbeck Matthew Bieringer | 3:16.01a | SUNY Cortland | |
| 2. | - | Segun Olopo Mike Conti Noah Dunham Matthew Harden | 3:16.14a | Illinois Wesleyan | |
| 3. | - | A J Hollanquest Jared Morris Kevin Lofy Ben Zill | 3:16.22a | Wisconsin-Oshkosh | |
| 4. | - | Alex Rooker Ryan Mendez Jon Doble Dylan Randolph | 3:16.90a | Wisconsin-La Crosse | |
| - | Relay Team | DQ | Wheaton (IL) College | |