| 1. | Sr | Javier Garcia-Tunon | 51.63a | Florida State | |
| 3. | So | Joshua James | 54.23a | Kennesaw State | |
| 4. | Sr | Delandus O'Neal | 54.37a | Mississippi State | |
| 5. | So | Drew Franklin | 55.69a | Winthrop | |
| 6. | Sr | Michael Fingado | 55.88a | Florida State | |
| 7. | Jr | Wesley Marsh | 56.22a | Claflin | |
| 8. | Fr | Eric Kasunich | 56.47a | Winthrop | |
| 9. | Fr | Brian Graham | 56.88a | Kennesaw State | |
| 10. | So | David Allen | 57.11a | Slippery Rock | |
| 11. | Jr | Ben Edwards | 57.20a | York College (PA) | |
| 12. | Jr | Jeremy Easley | 57.61a | Kennesaw State | |
| 13. | Fr | Andrew Nottingham | 57.84a | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 14. | Fr | Evan Gerish | 58.45a | Winthrop | |
| 15. | Sr | Bryant Clifton | 58.46a | Winthrop | |
| 16. | So | Jason Borst | 58.78a | Edinboro U of PA | |
| 17. | Fr | Dan Hedglin | 58.98a | Slippery Rock | |
| 18. | Sr | Eric Novick | 59.38a | Slippery Rock | |
| 19. | Sr | Grant Burton | 1:00.31a | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 20. | Sr | Mike Rose | 1:00.72a | Slippery Rock | |
| 21. | Jr | Ryan Campbell | 1:00.75a | York College (PA) | |
| 22. | Sr | Robert Coehoorn | 1:00.87a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 23. | Fr | Jimmie Johnson | 1:01.12a | Edward Waters | |
| 24. | Jr | Lawrence Inman | 1:01.43a | Claflin | |
| 25. | So | Eric Hein | 1:01.47a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 26. | Jr | Brady Wert | 1:02.20a | Slippery Rock | |
| 27. | Fr | Tyler Hoeffner | 1:02.83a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 28. | Fr | Alan Snodgrass | 1:03.35a | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 29. | So | Tyler Hickox | 1:03.60a | York College (PA) | |
| 30. | Fr | Damarcus Henley | 1:03.87a | Kennesaw State | |
| 31. | Fr | Tyler Larson | 1:04.21a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 32. | Fr | Joe Spears | 1:04.26a | Slippery Rock | |
| 33. | Fr | Alex Hirschy | 1:04.48a | Slippery Rock | |
| 34. | Fr | Tom Monteverde | 1:04.86a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 35. | So | Steven Doocy | 1:07.58a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 36. | Fr | Joe Klimowicz | 1:08.02a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| -- | Sr | Dwayne Cormier | DNS | Edward Waters | |
| -- | Fr | Tim Lang | DNS | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| -- | So | Andrew Jacobs | DNS | Florida State | |
| -- | Fr | Arthur Weborg | DNS | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| -- | Fr | Dwight Holden | DNS | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| -- | Jr | Greg Bynes | DNS | Florida A&M | |
| -- | Jr | Damarius Carroll | DNS | Florida A&M | |
| -- | So | Collin Anderson | DNS | Slippery Rock | |
| -- | Jr | Collin Lomagistro | DNS | Florida State | |
| 1. | - | Kendall May Deangelo Cherry Dwight Mullings Justin Christian | 40.13a | Mississippi State | |
| 2. | - | LaJarvis Cook Craig Scott Joe Washington Carl McKinzie | 41.72a | Florida A&M | |
| 3. | - | Joshua James Antonio Logan Kendall Parks Jemir Martinez | 42.05a | Kennesaw State | |
| 4. | - | Andre Reid Matt Habermehl Daniel Stephenson Michael Bejarano | 42.82a | Florida International | |
| 5. | - | Khalfani Lawson David Tansey James Verdi Steven Wilson | 43.14a | Kennesaw State | |
| 6. | - | Gabe Henise Mark Ksiezopolski Thomas Kentouris Darren McKoy | 43.75a | York College (PA) | |
| 7. | - | Nate Harwell Kevin Diederich Brian Seniuk Kyle Rate | 44.51a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 8. | - | Travis Knight Quinton Warren Reginald Wise Deaaron McCannon | 44.97a | Edward Waters | |
| 9. | - | Relay Team | 45.91a | York College (PA) | |
| 10. | - | Relay Team | 46.20a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | DNF | Winthrop | |
| -- | - | patrick Wright Paul Davis Benjamin Charbonneau Zach Lynch | DNF | Lake Superior State | |
| -- | - | Ricky Kump Michael Meadows Sami Hart Dwight Holden | DNS | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| -- | - | Kyle Vicks Aaron Dorn-Long Wesley Marsh John Hill | DNS | Claflin | |
| 1. | - | Emmanuel Mayers John Bailey O'Neal Wilder Dwight Mullings | 3:11.39a | Mississippi State | |
| 2. | - | David Tansey Joshua James Daniel Grass James Verdi | 3:15.39a | Kennesaw State | |
| 3. | - | Kyle Vicks Aaron Dorn-Long Wesley Marsh John Hill | 3:15.64a | Claflin | |
| 4. | - | Daquam Lee Mark Williams Craig Scott Stanley Suber | 3:20.10a | Florida A&M | |
| 5. | - | Daryl Brady Martin Lee Tevarus Christian Antione Lipscomb | 3:22.31a | Mississippi State | |
| 6. | - | Andre Reid Pedro Bigorra Michael Bejarano Charles Sutton | 3:23.88a | Florida International | |
| 7. | - | Brian Graham Jeremy Easley Gianni Catalano Jemir Martinez | 3:24.43a | Kennesaw State | |
| 8. | - | Matthew Cameron Cameron Vincent Thuom Mathiang Kendrick Poullard | 3:25.48a | Mississippi State | |
| 9. | - | Michael Guntner Robert Thornton Khalfani Lawson Damarcus Henley | 3:26.73a | Kennesaw State | |
| 10. | - | patrick Wright Evan Williams Zach Lynch Paul Davis | 3:27.67a | Lake Superior State | |
| 11. | - | Relay Team | 3:28.01a | Edinboro U of PA | |
| 12. | - | Mark Van Alstyne Ben Bichler Dominic Maio Brian Seniuk | 3:29.89a | Milwaukee School of Engine... | |
| 13. | - | Relay Team | 3:30.79a | Florida International | |
| 14. | - | Roberto Armenteros Quinton Warren Deaaron McCannon Reginald Wise | 3:31.27a | Edward Waters | |
| 15. | - | Relay Team | 3:34.14a | Edward Waters | |
| 16. | - | Jason Vitek Joe Lockard Nouri Stokes Jesse Watts | 3:35.18a | Lake Erie | |
| 17. | - | Relay Team | 3:40.41a | York College (PA) | |
| 18. | - | Tyler Hickox Ryan Campbell Mike Amatuccio Kevin Carullo | 3:43.39a | York College (PA) | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | DNS | Florida State | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | DNS | Slippery Rock | |
| -- | - | Dwight Holden John Natow Sami Hart Kevoy Douglas | DNS | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| -- | - | Delandus O'Neal Deangelo Cherry Justin Christian Kendall May | DNS | Mississippi State | |