| 1. | - | Princeton Bryson Matt Moffett Destin Heasley Curtis Eaton | 3:15.99a | Kent State | |
| 2. | - | Burton Clarke Kelli Thibou Alan Laws Jamaal Devore | 3:17.03a | Delaware State | |
| 3. | - | Deven Keene Stephen Miles Dominic Colvin Justin Ware | 3:18.28a | Tiffin | |
| 4. | - | Tyquan Brown Kevaughn Laviea Ryan Carter Edward Hurley | 3:18.44a | Delaware State | |
| 5. | - | Limiel Hodge Johnny Dogun Idris Kasumu Caleb Matthews | 3:20.96a | Pittsburgh | |
| 7. | - | Relay Team | 3:21.60a | California U of PA | |
| 8. | - | Cedric Rainey Aaron Anderson Lamar Veale Lawrence Campbell | 3:21.81a | Hampton | |
| 9. | - | Victor Garcia Justen Johnson Brandon Marlow Casey Aylesworth | 3:24.75a | Mansfield | |
| 10. | - | Relay Team | 3:26.01a | Slippery Rock | |
| 11. | - | Relay Team | 3:26.93a | Tiffin | |
| 12. | - | Relay Team | 3:27.40a | Lake Erie | |
| 13. | - | Travis McKinley Mike Little Travis Hamrick Brandon McKinley | 3:27.74a | Wheeling Jesuit | |
| 14. | - | Relay Team | 3:28.34a | California U of PA | |
| 15. | - | Jordan Selfe Jason Shelnick Andrew Moore Sylvester Watts | 3:28.88a | Tiffin | |
| 16. | - | Jordan Hoppel Nate Logan Thor Lindsey Cory Lemar | 3:29.86a | Ashland | |
| 17. | - | Charles Gladman Michael Robinson Tyler Morton DJ Smith | 3:30.60a | Robert Morris (PA) | |
| 18. | - | David Gibson Kurtis Polacek Brian Armstrong Ben Lawrence | 3:33.01a | Xavier (OH) | |
| 19. | - | Joe Candito Nicholas Thomas Ben Wagner Donovan Powell | 3:38.30a | Tiffin | |
| 20. | - | Relay Team | 3:42.59a | Wheeling Jesuit | |
| 21. | - | Nick Williams Ben Rumbaugh Ryan Ulmer Desmond Dodd | 3:47.07a | Xavier (OH) | |
| 22. | - | Relay Team | 3:47.59a | John Carroll | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | DNF | Kent State | |
| -- | - | Anthony Casciano Samuel Perkins Jerome Lowery Kevin Wilbank | DNF | Pittsburgh | |
| 1. | Fr | Korbin Smith | 22-11.75 | Ohio State | |
| 2. | Jr | Damon Dixon | 22-05.00 | Hampton | |
| 4. | Jr | Michael Schober | 21-10.75 | Kent State | |
| 7. | Jr | Keith Onto | 21-06.25 | Maryland-Baltimore County | |
| 10. | Fr | Heath Nickles | 20-08.00 | Ohio State | |
| 12. | Sr | Michael Buccheri | 20-07.75 | Maryland-Baltimore County | |
| 13. | Sr | Lamar Veale | 20-06.25 | Hampton | |
| 14. | Jr | Martin Nevarez | 20-05.25 | Maryland-Baltimore County | |
| 15. | Sr | Dan Snyder | 20-04.50 | Tiffin | |
| 17. | Sr | Stephen Ramsey | 20-03.50 | Hampton | |
| 18. | Jr | Dominic Devaud | 20-01.50 | Maryland-Baltimore County | |
| 19. | Sr | Brady Wert | 19-11.50 | Slippery Rock | |
| 22. | Sr | Shane McLaughlin | 19-02.75 | Malone | |
| 24. | Fr | Cuylor Edgell | 18-10.50 | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 25. | Fr | Isaac Snyder | 18-10.00 | Lake Erie | |
| 26. | Sr | Ricky Kump | 18-08.50 | West Virginia Wesleyan | |
| 27. | Fr | Andrew Greenslade | 18-06.00 | Slippery Rock | |
| 28. | So | Dean Wood | 13-05.00 | Kent State | |