| 1. | - | Gerkenz Senesca Riker Hylton Chris Brown Triedecio Davis | 41.83a | Essex County | |
| 2. | - | Chris Medina Kyle Gilroy Rob Jiggetts Kyle Magliaro | 42.07a | College of New Jersey | |
| 3. | - | Shariff Stubbs Justin Booker Keron Goodridge Kevon Brown | 44.05a | Rutgers-Newark | |
| 4. | - | Elijah Johnson Willie Anderson Khalif Church Shehab Uddin | 46.46a | Gloucester County | |
| 5. | - | Joseph Reyes Anthony Poto Brian Leary Max James | 46.54a | St Joseph's-Long Island | |
| 6. | - | Darnell Armstrong Justin Madden David Chin Adrian Dejesus | 48.61a | Middlesex County | |
| -- | - | Brian Drollette Nate Williams Josh Garren Peter Hamm | DQ | SUNY Plattsburgh | |
| -- | - | Greg McLeod Olugbenga Olutossin David Echevarria Mohamed Abuouf | DNF | Stevens IT (NJ) | |
| -- | - | Jean LeBlanc Joe Badru Imoleme Ilogienboh Barry Clark | DNF | Kean | |
| 1. | - | Chris Brown Anthony Davis Riker Hylton Triedecio Davis | 3:17.96a | Essex County | |
| 2. | - | Justin Worthing DeShard Stevens Steven Murray Rob McGowan | 3:18.49a | College of New Jersey | |
| 3. | - | Sean Wren Tim Greenberg Sean Bernstein Sean Daly | 3:20.51a | SUNY Oneonta | |
| 4. | - | Matt Gough Barry Clark Doug Bonner Ricardo Garcia | 3:20.64a | Kean | |
| 5. | - | Darnell Gatling II Irfan Anwar Rishawn Marshal Oscar Kamalu | 3:32.60a | CUNY Lehman | |
| 6. | - | Taylor Purdue Nick Huddy Dan Collier Brian Makinson | 3:33.48a | Rowan | |
| 7. | - | Steven Caracena Mark Edwards Michael Brown Christopher Kailath | 3:33.88a | Bergen | |
| 8. | - | Relay Team | 3:35.24a | SUNY Oneonta | |
| 9. | - | Keron Goodridge Gerard Farao Mathew Bond Tauqeer Qazi | 3:36.16a | Rutgers-Newark | |
| 10. | - | Dan Kurz Matthew Heck Gabriel Ryan Brian King | 3:38.05a | Swarthmore | |
| 11. | - | Adam Biner George Chukwueze Osi Eigbe Brandin Frasier | 3:38.55a | Rutgers-Camden | |
| 12. | - | Shuan Al-Hassan Khalif Church Greg Taylor Courtney Clayton | 3:38.84a | Gloucester County | |
| 13. | - | Chris Sneed Jared Reynolds Dan Bruton Chuck Hollister | 3:38.87a | SUNY Oneonta | |
| 14. | - | Charles Awe Macalbert Jeantus Tchaz Amevor Rolland Ying | 3:52.01a | Rutgers-Newark | |