| 1. | Jr | Bryan Beegle | 15:02.80a | Shippensburg | |
| 2. | Fr | Jeremiah Wilt | 15:09.48a | Hagerstown | |
| 3. | Fr | Dominic Camasso | 15:11.01a | Seton Hill | |
| 4. | Fr | Dustin Adams | 15:14.50a | Shippensburg | |
| 5. | Sr | Matthew Bailey | 15:17.37a | Juniata | |
| 6. | | Andrew Pitts | 15:20.98a | Unattached | |
| 7. | | Kieran Hennessy | 15:22.42a | Unattached | |
| 8. | So | Corey Centofonti | 15:28.21a | Hagerstown | |
| 9. | Fr | John Reilly | 15:34.37a | Shippensburg | |
| 10. | So | Wade Miller | 15:35.04a | Hagerstown | |
| 11. | Fr | Christopher Poss | 15:38.60a | California U of PA | |
| 12. | Fr | Jonathan Bogert | 15:43.59a | Seton Hill | |
| 13. | Fr | Brandon Mauch | 15:48.87a | Hagerstown | |
| 14. | Jr | Kevin Rodgers | 15:50.92a | Kutztown | |
| 15. | Jr | Thomas Daniels | 15:52.27a | Gettysburg | |
| 16. | | Mark Eissens | 15:54.39a | Unat-Shippen | |
| 17. | Fr | Nathaniel Clark | 15:55.84a | Hagerstown | |
| 18. | Fr | Joe Dyas | 15:56.79a | Kutztown | |
| 19. | Sr | Eric Reger | 15:58.43a | California U of PA | |
| 20. | Fr | John Wallace | 16:04.06a | Lebanon Valley | |
| 21. | Sr | Andrew Reed | 16:04.40a | Gettysburg | |
| 22. | Fr | Justin Weaver | 16:04.88a | Seton Hill | |
| 23. | Fr | Chris Farmer | 16:05.35a | Elizabethtown | |
| 24. | So | Zach Hoagland | 16:06.07a | Messiah | |
| 25. | Fr | Chris Werner | 16:06.48a | California U of PA | |
| 26. | Fr | Matt Seeley | 16:07.78a | Elizabethtown | |
| 27. | So | Steve Esposito | 16:15.55a | Kutztown | |
| 28. | So | Matthew Herring | 16:28.44a | Messiah | |
| 29. | Jr | Beau Wilson | 16:30.05a | Messiah | |
| 30. | Fr | Brendan Kane | 16:52.08a | Susquehanna | |
| 31. | So | Gabriel Lincoln-Decusatis | 17:00.01a | Lebanon Valley | |
| 32. | Fr | Steven Andrews | 17:08.44a | York College (PA) | |
| 33. | Fr | John Lugg | 17:33.33a | Juniata | |
| 34. | Sr | Blair Ames | 17:41.15a | Hood | |
| 35. | Sr | Brendan Greenlees | 17:44.40a | Hood | |
| 36. | So | Javier Skwara | 17:51.11a | York College (PA) | |
| 37. | So | Barry Kistler | 18:16.60a | Seton Hill | |
| 38. | Fr | Murray Beachtel | 18:16.88a | Messiah | |
| 39. | Fr | Connor Unger | 18:20.69a | Albright | |
| 40. | Sr | Christopher Bollinger | 18:26.95a | Albright | |
| -- | So | Jim Myers | DNF | Gettysburg | |
| 1. | - | Thomas Kentouris Damian Myers Ryan Liggitt Darren McKoy | 42.11a | York College (PA) | |
| 2. | | Relay Team | 42.63a | Unat-Shippensburg | |
| 3. | - | Greg Crawford Kendel Dixon Percell Berry Matt Cannell | 42.64a | Kutztown | |
| 4. | - | Jonathan Dennis Aron Kurzinski Nick Spino Sean Randall | 42.64a | Seton Hill | |
| 5. | - | Michael Treese Kyle Dickinson Tyrek Nelson DJ Greene | 43.21a | Shippensburg | |
| 6. | - | Pat Doughty Kyle Grimm Mike Mauger Wyatt Eaton | 43.48a | Elizabethtown | |
| 7. | - | Jacob Hochard Nick Rosenberger Sean Thon Tom Senseney | 43.91a | Gettysburg | |
| 8. | - | Justin Lee Caleb Wiley Wes Rockwell Joshua Light | 43.97a | Lebanon Valley | |
| 9. | - | Brandon Walters Dan Ward Brian Allport Chris Niles | 44.00a | Elizabethtown | |
| 10. | - | Ray Irizarry Justin Taylor Dane Lonsdale Sean Denson | 44.54a | Dickinson | |
| 11. | | Relay Team | 44.75a | Ship Alum | |
| 12. | - | Tyler Scruggs Garrett Daley Anthony Tossounian Rashidi Jackson | 44.89a | Frostburg State | |
| 13. | - | Nicholas Bauer TJ Breya Aaron McCoy Alex Shope | 45.54a | Juniata | |
| 14. | - | Daniel Simmons Clark Runciman Oshane Rennie George Cook | 45.81a | Albright | |
| 15. | - | Joshua Byler Max Fritsche Chris Vasaturo Drew Melnick | 46.28a | Messiah | |
| -- | - | Ryan Drzeweicki Greg Lawson Jon Bennett Ken Kull | DNF | Shippensburg | |
| 1. | - | Relay Team | 3:18.49a | California U of PA | |
| 2. | - | Matt Cannell Kori Meshaw Eli Weeks Kendel Dixon | 3:19.79a | Kutztown | |
| 3. | - | Sean Wright Tarik Muhammad Markese Hayden Charles Jacobs | 3:21.02a | Frostburg State | |
| 4. | - | Joe Tavormina Percell Berry Jonathan Byrne Shaun Crump | 3:22.06a | Kutztown | |
| 5. | - | Dwight Phillips Toby Oduho Bobby Ralls Dadre Williams | 3:26.10a | California U of PA | |
| 6. | - | Ryan Trexler Alex Shope Nik Klena TJ Breya | 3:29.71a | Juniata | |
| 7. | - | Ryan Boyer Joel Flott Matt Gelety Joshua Neyhart | 3:31.74a | Shippensburg | |
| 8. | - | Tyler Scruggs Thomas Bennett Steven Flanagan Kevin Wright | 3:32.29a | Frostburg State | |
| 9. | - | Robby Caulfield Mike Harahan Dan Sodroski Chance King | 3:32.34a | Susquehanna | |
| 10. | - | Todd Phillips Kyle Raguz Marcus Line Eric Wolfe | 3:32.79a | Shippensburg | |
| 11. | - | Pat Doughty Aaron Focht Jake Blanton Matt Jensen | 3:34.79a | Elizabethtown | |
| 12. | - | Miguel Montano Jordan Calloway Garrett Daley Calvin Shriver | 3:34.97a | Frostburg State | |
| 13. | - | Oshane Rennie George Cook Justin Gewirtz Daniel Simmons | 3:37.10a | Albright | |
| 14. | - | Michael Donovan David Kalatshoff Tyler Powell Bakari Thompson | 3:41.83a | California U of PA | |
| 15. | - | Richard Pennisi Craig Hutcheson Taylor Munoz Jeff Smeiles | 3:44.05a | Messiah | |
| -- | - | Shane Harvey Greg Crawford Manny Morris Jacob Murray | DNF | Kutztown | |