| 1. | - | Joseph Leyland Brandon Tolliver Demar Sheffey Tom McKrill | 42.60a | Notre Dame College | |
| 2. | - | Travis McKinley Jason Forrester Brandon McKinley Mike Little | 42.72a | Wheeling Jesuit | |
| 3. | - | Charles Pratt Ben Russell Brandon Stallworth Scott Thomas | 43.04a | Mt Union | |
| 4. | - | Bryan Wideman Bill Zaccardelli Denny Love Matt Mihalich | 43.95a | John Carroll | |
| 5. | - | Jordan Telin Craig Webb Vinnie Krawiec Gregory Benscoter | 44.32a | Penn State-Erie-Behr... | |
| 6. | - | Avrin Bell Quincy Bruton Justin Brewton Kashif Walls | 44.76a | West Liberty Univers... | |
| -- | - | Tony Mihalich Drew Krainz Mike Minjock Matt Szep | 44.78a | John Carroll | |
| 7. | - | Patrik Miller Lester Bragg Timothy Claybaugh Tim Palma | 45.63a | Grove City | |
| 8. | - | Trale Merz Tom Hudson Abdul Yusuff Jordan Wrask | 45.66a | Waynesburg | |
| 9. | - | Aaron Steensma Andrew Saff Ross Doucette Dave Johnson | 45.77a | Roberts Wesleyan | |
| 10. | - | Patrick Meier Tim Michaud Nolan Cleary Hunter Mason | 47.94a | Franciscan | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | 48.40a | Grove City | |
| -- | - | Daniel Farray Raymear Pinchom Ed Holmes Taylor McNeil | DQ | Bethany (WV) | |
| 1. | - | Travis McKinley Travis Hamrick Brandon McKinley David Johnson | 3:23.71a | Wheeling Jesuit | |
| 2. | - | Cory Hoover Ben Russell Kris Claros Korey Smerk | 3:25.40a | Mt Union | |
| 3. | - | Bill Zaccardelli David Hickey Anthony Colbert Tony Mihalich | 3:27.95a | John Carroll | |
| 4. | - | Daniel Bridenstine Christopher Sinick Bryan Krieger Garrett Oliver | 3:30.41a | Malone | |
| 5. | - | Jordan Telin Michael Johnson Steve Monnie Craig Webb | 3:30.46a | Penn State-Erie-Behr... | |
| 6. | - | Ross Lenehan Kyle Crismon Stephen Webb Tom Gay | 3:30.55a | Notre Dame College | |
| 7. | - | Raymear Pinchom Matt Schrumpf Ed Holmes Joe Douglas | 3:33.94a | Bethany (WV) | |
| -- | - | David Bowman Chad Henson Tyler Glover Matt Mason | 3:36.31a | Wheeling Jesuit | |
| -- | - | Robert Houston Gregory Benscoter Kevin Forish Nick Marzka | 3:37.55a | Penn State-Erie-Behr... | |
| -- | - | Aaron Sharp John Jackson Spencer German Ian Johnson | 3:39.73a | John Carroll | |
| 8. | - | Travis Beihl Kaison Rohrabaugh Stefan Riggs Jeremiah Propst | 3:42.34a | West Liberty Univers... | |
| 9. | - | Kevin Gallagher Lester Bragg Timothy Claybaugh Jeff Tharnish | 3:43.61a | Grove City | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | 3:45.11a | Grove City | |
| 10. | - | Trale Merz Casey Kaiser William Moder Michael Harwick | 3:46.71a | Waynesburg | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | 3:51.54a | Grove City | |
| -- | - | David Suhan David Robinson-Gault Kyle Markwardt Grier Walker | 3:53.37a | Penn State-Erie-Behr... | |