| 1. | - | Pat Reaney Robert Robinson Donnie Lesnick Chris Leibrand | 3:19.67a | Lewis | |
| 2. | - | Chris Malaya Ben Harmon Dan Davis Pierre Hoppenot | 3:20.81a | Washington U in St. ... | |
| 3. | - | Jonathan Caron Dayton Henrikson Jon Howard Scott Foley | 3:22.05a | North Central | |
| 4. | - | Luke Vance Kyle Kunz Will Phillips Parker Thompson | 3:27.37a | Wheaton (IL) College | |
| 5. | - | Jon Biancardi Joe Schneiderbauer Jacob Austin Tyler Sheehan | 3:27.71a | North Central | |
| 6. | - | James Hoffman Nick Galanes Delaney Fluker Joey Michals | 3:32.08a | North Central | |
| 7. | - | Dylan Roff Ryan Serafino Clark Poro Minhaj Ghayur | 3:33.63a | Benedictine (IL) | |
| 8. | - | Tyler Jackson Alex Molinari Spencer Gordon Ben Cutting | 3:35.67a | Washington U in St. ... | |
| 9. | - | Relay Team | 3:36.37a | North Central | |
| 10. | - | Marc Erickson Lance Russ Ben Dagg Caleb Cutherell | 3:37.35a | Wheaton (IL) College | |
| 11. | - | Eric Oros John Reasor Zach Weber Kyle Nichol | 3:38.60a | North Central | |
| 12. | - | Relay Team | 3:39.06a | North Central | |
| 13. | - | James Pierce Jon Poppe Sal Montes Nate Poppe | 3:40.67a | Concordia-Chicago | |
| 14. | - | Garrett Dorsey Jesus Escareno Tom Johnson Travis Pruitt | 3:42.07a | Harper | |
| 15. | - | Matt Rickard Josh Lewis Chris Brennan Tim Meahl | 3:44.54a | Washington U in St. ... | |
| 16. | - | Michael Richardson Kenny Fairleigh Jon Wignes Patrick Ryan | 3:44.98a | Washington U in St. ... | |
| 17. | - | Josh Garrett Nicholas Penev Nicholas Cramer Andrew Urani | 3:50.07a | North Central | |
| 18. | - | Relay Team | 3:51.07a | Lewis | |
| 19. | - | Joe Standard Ross Roggow Danny Van Dyke Jeremy Browning | 3:51.81a | Wheaton (IL) College | |
| 20. | - | Alex Arman Tyler Zachary Danny Graham Tom Brown | 4:00.26a | Benedictine (IL) | |
| -- | - | Cody Laseman Jacob Paulus Yonaton Mascote Ross Helberg | DNF | North Central | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | DNS | North Central | |
| -- | - | Relay Team | DNS | Washington U in St. ... | |
| 1. | - | Matt Brinkmeier Jonathan Caron Jordan Kremer Joe McAvoy | 10:21.17a | North Central | |
| 2. | - | Luke Vance Pete Stearns Alec Shunk Clayton Loy | 10:27.14a | Wheaton (IL) College | |