| 1 | 27 | Saint Vincent,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:11:35.4 | Spread (1st 5) 45.6 |
| 2, 3, 6, 7, 9, (12), (13) |
| Chansler Poole, Jeff Hite, Kevin Wanichko, Andrew Razanauskas, Ryan Barlow, (Matt Hagg), (Cam Stumme) |
| 25:53.1, 26:11.5, 26:25.0, 26:27.1, 26:38.7, (26:59.5), (27:05.2) |
| 2 | 70 | Grove City,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:14:28.5 | Spread (1st 5) 2:15.4 |
| 1, 15, 16, 17, 21, (23), (24) |
| Garrett Cichowitz, Arleigh McRae, Mark Talbott, Alec Schultz, Timothy Cole, (Wesley Coopersmith), (Francis Ridge) |
| 25:21.2, 27:08.8, 27:09.4, 27:12.5, 27:36.6, (27:47.1), (27:50.0) |
| 3 | 96 | Geneva,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:17:33.0 | Spread (1st 5) 1:44.4 |
| 10, 11, 19, 27, 29, (33), (35) |
| Nick Edinger, Jon Shope, Ryan Thorn, Owen Struck, Andrew Maienshein, (Jacob Beschner), (Charles Walters) |
| 26:40.9, 26:54.7, 27:24.2, 28:07.9, 28:25.3, (28:39.7), (29:04.2) |
| 4 | 105 | Thiel,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:18:35.6 | Spread (1st 5) 3:17.3 |
| 4, 8, 22, 30, 41, (53) |
| Richard Peterson, Regis Wagner, Brendan DuLaney, Sam Slaven, Derek Workman, (Ethan Rowe) |
| 26:17.3, 26:34.1, 27:39.1, 28:30.5, 29:34.6, (31:26.0) |
| 5 | 143 | Washington & Jefferson,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:21:40.9 | Spread (1st 5) 3:47.2 |
| 5, 20, 26, 45, 47, (60), (61) |
| Scott Ryan, Benjamin Kopchick, Andrew Howard, Bradley Hanne, Richard Koch, (Anthony Bocchine), (Alexander Mey) |
| 26:17.4, 27:24.4, 28:04.1, 29:50.4, 30:04.6, (33:06.0), (33:07.4) |
| 6 | 168 | Thomas More (Ky.),
KY - Team Time (1st 5) 2:24:59.9 | Spread (1st 5) 4:33.1 |
| 14, 25, 31, 43, 55, (59) |
| Matt Wurtzler, Andrew Linkugel, Luke Behler, Andrew Fuller, Kyle Egan, (Joel Daley) |
| 27:05.5, 27:57.7, 28:34.4, 29:43.7, 31:38.6, (32:49.9) |
| 7 | 185 | Waynesburg,
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:25:38.6 | Spread (1st 5) 1:17.8 |
| 28, 36, 39, 40, 42, (44), (49) |
| Adam Swingle, Jonathan Blatt, Kameron Schaefer, Justin Angotti, William Bill Moder, (Kyle Edwards), (Aaron Anderson) |
| 28:19.2, 29:07.2, 29:14.2, 29:21.0, 29:37.0, (29:46.0), (30:20.0) |
| 8 | 192 | Westminster (Pa.),
PA - Team Time (1st 5) 2:26:29.9 | Spread (1st 5) 2:12.1 |
| 32, 34, 37, 38, 51, (54), (57) |
| Aaron Sutton, Morgan Hanes, Justin Jones, Kyle Filicky, Josh Caldwell, (Taylor Walter), (Colin Feeney) |
| 28:35.0, 28:40.8, 29:13.0, 29:14.0, 30:47.1, (31:32.0), (31:59.3) |
| 9 | 214 | Bethany (W.Va.),
WV - Team Time (1st 5) 2:29:12.5 | Spread (1st 5) 3:33.8 |
| 18, 46, 48, 50, 52, (56), (58) |
| Cory Yarrington, Joe Douglas, Hunter Ankrom, Brandon Miller, Ryan Hajney, (John Hajney), (Joshua Wentz) |
| 27:23.3, 30:03.6, 30:06.0, 30:42.5, 30:57.1, (31:49.6), (32:06.0) |
