| 1 | 34 | Anderson (Ind.),
IN - Team Time (1st 5) 1:47:03.4 | Spread (1st 5) 1:16.0 |
| 1, 5, 7, 9, 12, (13), (14) |
| Jona Odell, Calen Bruner, Ian Leatherman, Matthew Lawrence, RJ Claycomb, (Isaac Wonderlin), (Grayson Radvansky) |
| 20:48.1, 21:15.8, 21:18.6, 21:36.8, 22:04.1, (22:05.5), (22:19.1) |
| 2 | 59 | Franklin,
IN - Team Time (1st 5) 1:51:09.7 | Spread (1st 5) 2:05.0 |
| 3, 4, 15, 18, 19, (26), (30) |
| Clayton Brumfield, Evan Vernon, Claudio Gallegos, Adam Rector, Chris Ott, (Nathaniel Staples), (Sean Groves) |
| 21:03.5, 21:10.6, 22:39.1, 23:08.0, 23:08.5, (23:56.8), (24:31.4) |
| 3 | 71 | Transylvania,
KY - Team Time (1st 5) 1:52:47.9 | Spread (1st 5) 2:18.3 |
| 6, 11, 16, 17, 21, (22), (31) |
| Charlie Jordan, Evan Reister, Jordan Hancock, Michael Clore, Brian Mudrak, (Giovanni Hernandez), (Nicolas Johnston) |
| 21:18.2, 21:46.9, 22:58.7, 23:07.6, 23:36.5, (23:49.6), (24:33.8) |
| 4 | 72 | Earlham,
IN - Team Time (1st 5) 1:52:04.7 | Spread (1st 5) 3:09.3 |
| 2, 8, 10, 24, 28, (34), (35) |
| Gabriel Penk, Daniel Kibet, Oliver Daniel, Jacob Kempinski, Ernesto Cabrera, (Yuvraj Bisht), (Riley Green) |
| 20:55.3, 21:27.4, 21:46.5, 23:50.9, 24:04.6, (29:02.0), (32:29.6) |
| 5 | 124 | Mount St. Joseph,
OH - Team Time (1st 5) 1:59:14.7 | Spread (1st 5) 54.7 |
| 20, 23, 25, 27, 29, (32), (33) |
| Chad Mason, Kevin Polking, Josh King, Alex Griffin, Drew Stark, (Sean McElroy), (Brandon Asbury) |
| 23:18.0, 23:50.6, 23:54.0, 23:59.4, 24:12.7, (25:22.8), (26:15.4) |
